ST_PitchFamily in dml-main.xsd

[John Haug]

Yikes, what did you dig up…!  There’s a limit to what I can find on this.  It appears a DR may not have been handled correctly years ago.  See WG 4 N 0230 for the change-tracked Part 1 COR 2 final draft.  The only DRs I can find that touch this simple type (and that may not be complete) are 09-0037, 09-0055 and 09-0056.  56 defers to 55 (https://onedrive.live.com/view.aspx/Public%20Documents/2009/DR-09-0055.docx?cid=C8BA0861DC5E4ADC).

09-0037 deletes in 19.2.1.13 font at charset, font at panose and font at pitchFamily; agreed in Stockholm in March 2010.  DR 09-0055 makes numerous changes; Chris’ changes of 2011-06-03 agreed in Berlin in June 2011.  Those changes in 09-0055 are not reflected in the draft in N 0230 or in Rex’s private COR drafts with DR traceback references.  I’m not sure what drove the changes in N 0230 – another DR I haven’t found or just an incorrect application of edits.

Here’s what I can piece together so far.

DR 09-0055 does… | N 0230 does…
19.2.1.13 font:
changes @pitchFamily | deletes @charset, @panose, @pitchFamily (references DR 09-0037 in Rex's private DR traceback doc)
20.1.10.87 ST_PitchFamily:
adds this new ST | does not exist
21.1.2.3.1 cs:
changes @pitchFamily | no changes
21.1.2.3.3 ea:
changes @pitchFamily | no changes
21.1.2.3.7 latin:
changes @pitchFamily (incl. removing a note) | adds the note (no DR referenced in Rex's doc)
21.1.2.3.10 sym:
changes @pitchFamily (incl. removing a note) | adds the note (no DR referenced in Rex's doc)
21.1.2.4.6 buFont:
changes @pitchFamily (incl. removing a note) | no changes (the note already exists)

Does anyone have any memory of this?

John

From: eb2mmrt at gmail.com [mailto:eb2mmrt at gmail.com] On Behalf Of MURATA Makoto
Sent: Saturday, July 4, 2015 1:55 AM
To: SC34
Subject: ST_PitchFamily in dml-main.xsd

Dear colleagues,

I checked all simple types in Part 1 XSD schemas.  All simple types
are documented in Part 1.  The only exception is ST_PitchFamily in
dml-main.xsd.  This simple type was introduced as part of COR2.

Regards,
Makoto
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.vse.cz/pipermail/sc34wg4/attachments/20150710/ca115e64/attachment.html>