JP-0003 for the Part1 DCOR1

MURATA Makoto (FAMILY Given) eb2m-mrt at asahi-net.or.jp
Thu Nov 26 02:54:13 CET 2009


(Wearing my Japanese hat)

The oirignal comment is as follows:

	Validation by major validators 
	 
	As part of the vote on DIS 29500, Japan 
	pointed out interoperability problems of the XSD schemas and
	requested that they should be processible by major validators
	such as MSXML, Xerces-J, and MSV.  This comment was accepted and
	the schemas have been modified (see the BRM resolution 39). 
	However, after the DCOR was sent for a ballot, it was pointed
	out that earlier versions of MSXML cannot handle OOXML XSD
	schemas.

We find that MSXML4,  MSXML5,  and .NET 2.0 validators fail to handle
the OOXML schemas correctly.  One sollution is to ignore these old validators. 
 
But if we get rid of the id attribute, as proposed by Jirka Kosek in DR
09-0279, will things be better?  This DR is available at:

http://www.itscj.ipsj.or.jp/sc34/wg4/DR/00294.pdf

Cheers,
Makoto


More information about the sc34wg4 mailing list